ISRAEL: The views of Yury Avnety

Brian Hamlin forwards "this excellent piece by liberal Israeli commentator, Yuri Avneri. Violent men, be they Hitler or Sharon. always over-reach themselves and so ultimately self-destruct. For the full text, see "Uri Avnery" (avnery@actcom.co.il) 13.4.02: It should be unnecessary to explain that posting does not mean endorsement.

"105 years ago, the day after the First Zionist Congress in Basel, Theodor Herzl, wrote in his diary: In Basel I founded the State of the Jews. This week, Ariel Sharon should note in his diary: In Jenin I founded the State of the Palestinians. Of course, he did not mean to. Quite the contrary, his intention was to destroy the Palestinian nation, its institutions and leadership, once and for all, leaving only bits and pieces, human wreckage that could be disposed of anywhere. In practice, something quite different happened. Faced with the onslaught of the biggest military machine in the region and the most modern arms in the world,submerged in a sea of suffering, surrounded by bodies, the Palestinian nation straightened its back as never before. In the small refugee camp near Jenin a group of Palestinian fighters from all the organizations gathered for a battle of defense that will be enshrined forever in the hearts of all Arabs. This is the Palestinian Massada as an Israeli officer called it, alluding to the legendary stand of the remnants of the great Jewish rebellion against Rome in the year 71 AD.

When the international media cannot be kept out anymore and the pictures of horror will be published, two possible versions may emerge: Jenin as a story of massacre, a second Sabra and Shatila, and Jenin, the Palestinian Stalingrad, a story of immortal heroism.The second will surely prevail. Nations are built on myths. I was raised on the myths of Massada and Tel-Chai, they formed the consciousness of the new Hebrew nation. (In Tel-Chai, 1920, a roup of Jewish defenders, led by the one-armed hero Josef Trumpeldor, were killed in an incident with anti-French Syrian fighters.) The myths of Jenin and Arafats compound in Ramallah will form the consciousness of the new Palestinian nation. A primitive military robot, who sees everything in terms of fire-power and body-counts, will not understand this. But Napoleon, a military genius, said that in war, moral considerations account for three quarters, and the actual balance of force only for the other quarter.

How does Sharons war look in this perspective? As for the actual forces, the balance is clear. A few dozen Israelis killed, many hundreds of Palestinians dead. No destruction in Israel, horrible destruction in the Palestinian towns. The aim was, so it was claimed, to destroy the terror infrastructure. This definition is by itself nonsensical: the terror infrastructure exists in the souls of millions of Palestinians and tens of millions of Arabs, whose heart is bursting with rage. The more fighters and suicide-bombers are killed, the more fighters and suicide-bombers are ready to take their place. We saw the laboratories of explosives, some sacs of material obtainable in Israeli shops. The IDF is proud of discovering tens of them. There will soon be hundreds more. When dozens of wounded people lie around in the streets and slowly bleed to death, because the army shoots at every moving ambulance, it creates terrible hatred. When the army secretly buries hundreds of bodies of men, women and children, it creates terrible hatred. When tanks overrun cars, destroy houses, topple electricity poles, open water pipes, leave behind them thousands of homeless people and cause children to drink from puddles in the street, it causes terrible hatred. A Palestinian child, who sees all this with his eyes, becomes the suicide-bomber of tomorrow".

Ronald Hilton - 4/20/02