Other Discussions on Leaders

Two Idealists, Victims of Fate



When I first met Herbert Hoover in the early 40s, he was a grumpy, disillusioned man. He was sad because the wheel of fortune had tossed him to the ground. The more I study his life, the more impressive his early idealism becomes. He made some mistakes, such as signing the Smoot-Hawley bill, but they did not cause the Depression.

Salvador de Madariaga, whose influence at Oxford in the 30s inspired me to move from French to Hispanic Studies, was an idealist of a different kind. He wanted a peaceful world and a united Europe. His efforts at Geneva to make the League of Nations effective won for him the nickname Don Quixote de la Manchuria. He founded the College of Europe in Bruges. In retrospect, he was right, the world was wrong. He tried to make the Spanish Republic work, but Spain went crazy. I was evacuated on the first train from Madrid to Valencia after the first siege of Madrid. He followed a few days later. His life was threatened, mine less so. We met in Geneva; he was disillusioned, seeing all his efforts lost.

I have been re-reading his memoirs, Morning without Noon. He was Ambassador to Washington when Hoover was President. He took a strong dislike to him, and seemed to know little about Hoover the idealist. Presumably Hoover disliked him. Both were idealists, but in different ways and of different temperament. Hoover was always stern, while Madariaga was a lot of fun and excellent company. This is a good example of the importance of personalities in the chemistry of international affairs.

Ronald Hilton, 12-14-97


Webmaster